Back to Blog

Fable 5.2 vs Astra vs Neon vs Opus 5.5: 6.6x Cost Gap

Tutorials and Guides1530
Fable 5.2 vs Astra vs Neon vs Opus 5.5: 6.6x Cost Gap

November 2026 moved in a single direction: four flagship models shipped or refreshed within weeks of each other. GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 both landed on November 17. Gemini 4 Neon followed on November 18. Claude Opus 5.5 has been available since September 22. All four target agentic workloads. All four support roughly one million tokens of context. Input pricing sits between 3 and 8 USD per million tokens. And yet, at maximum reasoning effort, the cost of completing a single task differs by more than fivefold across the set.

The data below comes from vendor API documentation and the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1, verified on November 19, 2026.

Price and Specification: A Threefold Spread Behind Identical Positioning

ItemFable 5.2GPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 NeonOpus 5.5
Release2026-11-172026-11-172026-11-182026-09-22
Model IDclaude-fable-5-2gpt-6.2-astragemini-4-neonclaude-opus-5.5
Input (USD / 1M)8834
Output (USD / 1M)40401520
Cached read0.200.400.150.20
Context window1M1.05M1M1M
Max output128K128KNot statedNot stated
Reasoning tierslow / medium / high / xhigh / maxsamelow / medium / high / xhighlow / medium / high / xhigh / max
Default efforthighlowNot statedmax (always on)

Three deviations matter more than the headline prices.

Neon ships four tiers, not five. It has no max. Its top setting, xhigh, should be compared against other models’ xhigh, not against their max. Any ranking that ignores this overstates or understates Neon depending on which side of the comparison it sits.

Opus 5.5 cannot turn thinking off. Every request produces reasoning trace tokens, whether or not the task needs them. In agent frameworks that resend the same system prompt across hundreds of calls, that overhead compounds in a way flat pricing does not reveal.

Fable 5.2 reads cache at half of Astra’s rate. 0.20 versus 0.40 USD per million cached input tokens. On a single short conversation this is noise. On a 200K-token repository map resent every turn, it is the dominant line item.

Capability: Fable Leads the Index, Astra Leads the Cost Curve

ModelAA Intelligence IndexGlobal rankReasoning tier measuredOutput speedCost per task
Fable 5.265#1 / 92max111 tok/s26.54 USD
GPT-6.2 Astra62#3 / 92max64 tok/s4.00 USD
Gemini 4 Neon51—xhigh~110 tok/s6.44 USD
Opus 5.559—max117 tok/s10.04 USD

Fable 5.2 tops the index at 65. It is also 6.6x Astra’s per-task cost, 4.1x Neon’s, and 2.6x Opus 5.5’s. In development budgets that gap means one thing: the same task costs more. It does not automatically mean better output.

Two footnotes belong with the table.

Neon’s 51 is measured at xhigh, its own ceiling, not at a max tier it does not offer. If Google later opens a higher tier, that number could rise. Separately, Neon ranks first on the Agent-specific sub-index at 56.6 among the models tested here. That profile — moderate general intelligence, strong agent execution — describes a model whose capability is distributed evenly rather than concentrated in one extreme setting.

Opus 5.5 sits at 59 with a profile tilted toward throughput. At 117 tokens per second it is the fastest of the four, and it holds the shortest first-token latency in the group at roughly 333 milliseconds. In interactive settings that wait is visible; shorter latency also widens the range of tasks where the model feels responsive rather than sluggish.

Plot capability against per-task cost and the picture simplifies. Neon and Astra occupy the low-cost band and compete directly there. Opus 5.5 sits alone in the middle. Fable 5.2 is an outlier on both axes.

Five Scenarios, Five Recommendations

The governing rule is not “pick the highest score”. It is: at an acceptable quality floor, choose the model with the lowest per-task cost that clears that floor. Decisions should be made at the tier you will actually run, not at the ceiling.

Scenario one — complex mathematical proof, multi-step scientific reasoning, one-off hard tasks. Fable 5.2 at max. It holds the highest current capability ceiling. 26.54 USD per task is expensive, but for work that runs once and cannot be redone cheaply, the premium is defensible.

Scenario two — mid-to-high difficulty agent pipelines. Astra at high, or Neon at high. Astra’s 4.00 USD figure is already at max, so routine high-tier traffic costs less still. Neon at xhigh runs 6.44 USD with latency roughly a third of the alternatives in its class, which matters for teams running dense task queues rather than single long jobs.

Scenario three — knowledge work, long-document analysis, daily assistant duties. Opus 5.5 and Neon are the two credible picks. Opus 5.5 costs 10.04 USD per task at max; used at medium or high for practical work, that figure drops. Neon’s 3 USD input and 15 USD output give it a structural cost advantage on high-volume reading and summarization.

Scenario four — long system prompts reused across many calls (RAG and agent frameworks). Fable 5.2 and Opus 5.5 price cached reads at 0.20 and 0.15 respectively; Astra charges 0.40. Under heavy cache-hit rates, effective cost diverges sharply from list price, and Astra’s advantage in raw per-task cost narrows or inverts depending on prefix stability.

Scenario five — reading the pricing structure itself. List price is the wrong unit of comparison. Per-task cost at the measured tier is the right one: Fable 5.2 max 26.54, Opus 5.5 max 10.04, Neon xhigh 6.44, Astra max 4.00.

The mechanism behind those figures is token volume, not rate. In the AA evaluation, Fable 5.2 generates roughly 275,000 tokens per task at max, more than four times the median. Astra generates far fewer. When the business need is genuinely broad analytical expansion, that volume is the product being paid for. When the need is a compact, correct answer, it is waste.

And a boundary: these figures are AA evaluation workloads. They are not the cost of your production calls. Real agent token counts depend on workflow design, retry policy and context assembly.

Two Workloads, Two Different Cost Curves

Consider a team running 1,000 classification-and-summary tasks a month. Astra at max costs 4,000 USD. Fable 5.2 at max costs 26,540 USD. The capability difference on this task type is likely small. The spend difference is not.

Now consider 20 hard architectural analyses where a wrong conclusion costs a week of engineering. Astra costs 80 USD. Fable 5.2 costs 531 USD. Here the premium is trivial against the downside risk, and the extra three index points may pay for themselves in a single avoided mistake.

The same model set, two opposite conclusions. Cost per task is the right metric, and its value depends entirely on what the task is worth.

Operational Notes for Mixed Deployments

Running three or four of these models in one pipeline introduces its own overhead: four credential sets, four pricing sheets, four sets of rate limits, and a routing decision that has to be made per request rather than per project. Consolidating that behind a single access layer keeps the routing rules in one place, so a model swap changes one configuration entry rather than the client code. 4sapi provides that consolidated access layer for teams running mixed frontier workloads, which keeps per-model cost telemetry and fallback policy centrally visible.

Two configuration details are worth pinning down before any comparison is trusted. First, record the reasoning tier alongside every cost measurement; a “cheap” model at max and an “expensive” model at medium are not comparable. Second, cache read rates depend on prefix stability, so prompt structure affects the bill as much as the rate card does.

Common Questions

Neon versus Opus 5.5 — how to choose? Neon is cheaper on both axes: 3 USD versus 4 USD input, 6.44 versus 10.04 USD per task, and 15 versus 20 USD output. It also ranks first on the agent-specific sub-index at 56.6. For short-form content work, copy analysis and enterprise knowledge tasks, Neon is the better balance of cost and capability. Where the workload leans heavily on long mixed-media context, the two are closer than the price table suggests, since their cached read rates (0.15 and 0.20) are nearly equivalent.

Fable 5.2 leads the index — should it be the default? The index lead is real and the price lead is real, in opposite directions. At max, 100 tasks cost roughly 2,000 USD on Fable 5.2 against 400 USD on Astra. The way to settle it is empirical: run a batch of representative tasks on Fable 5.2 at medium, compare against Astra at high, and decide whether the measured quality difference justifies the multiple. Do not decide from the leaderboard alone.

Conclusion

Fable 5.2 holds the top index score at 65, and its 26.54 USD per-task figure positions it for work where cost is secondary and correctness is not.

Neon at 51 on the general index but first on the agent sub-index, at 6.44 USD per task, reshapes the mid-tier economics: agent-heavy workloads no longer require flagship pricing.

Astra is the most balanced across tiers and the cheapest at max, at 4.00 USD — the natural default for high-volume, latency-tolerant work.

Opus 5.5 leads on output speed at 117 tokens per second and first-token latency at about 333 ms, at a mid-range 10.04 USD per task, which suits responsive long-context and knowledge-intensive work.

The pattern worth carrying forward is not a ranking. It is that price, speed and intelligence no longer move together. Choosing by list price misleads; choosing by index score overspends; choosing by measured per-task cost at the tier you will actually run is the only comparison that survives contact with a budget.

Tags:Claude Fable 5.2GPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 NeonClaude Opus 5.5AnthropicOpenAIGoogle Gemini

Recommended reading

Explore more frontier insights and industry know-how.